Dear Reader,
Let’s be real when parents split up, one of the hardest, most emotional decisions is figuring out where the child will live. It's not just about who gets the bigger share of furniture or which car someone drives off with. We're talking about a child’s entire life where they’ll sleep, who helps with homework, who sees their first heartbreak up close, and who gets the morning cuddles. And when parents can’t agree, that decision ends up in the hands of a judge.
Now, if you’re going through this or know someone who is, you might wonder: what exactly does a judge look at when deciding who the child should live with? Is it about money? Is it about who’s the “better” parent? Or is it just a toss-up?
Let’s break it down together, no stiff legal jargon, no intimidating court lingo. Just honest talk about how judges make these tough decisions.
First and Foremost: The Child’s Best Interests
Judges always come back to one phrase: “the best interests of the child.” That’s the golden rule, the north star, the backbone of every decision. But here’s where it gets tricky: what does “best interest” even mean?
Well, it’s a bit of everything. Judges try to look at the full picture, not just one snapshot. They're trying to figure out which living arrangement is going to provide the safest, most stable, loving environment for the child to grow up in. It’s not about who can throw the biggest birthday party or who takes the most cute Instagram photos. It's deeper than that.
The Parent-Child Bond
One major thing judges look at is the relationship between the child and each parent. Does the child feel safe, heard, and loved? Is there a strong emotional connection?
If a child is very attached to one parent and not the other, that matters especially for younger kids who depend so heavily on consistent care. But here’s the kicker: just loving your child isn’t enough. Judges also look at how well you’re showing up for them.
- Are you involved in school stuff?
- Do you know their doctor’s name?
- Have you been the one waking up for night feeds or helping with potty training?
- Or have you just been popping in on weekends?
Judges want to know which parent is more present in the child’s everyday life.
Stability and Routine
Kids thrive on routine. Like, seriously bedtime stories at 8, waffles every Saturday, homework after dinner these little things create big feelings of safety. So, judges often favor the parent who can provide a more stable and predictable environment.
This includes:
- A consistent place to live
- A good school nearby
- A supportive community (friends, extended family, etc.)
- Emotional stability in the home (no yelling matches every night)
Let’s say one parent lives in a one-bedroom apartment and just moved in with a roommate, while the other parent owns a home near the child’s school, and has lived there for years. That matters. It doesn’t mean judges are judging your financial status, but consistency counts.
Willingness to Co-Parent
Here’s something that surprises a lot of people: judges don’t like drama. They’re not interested in punishing one parent because of past mistakes or letting someone “win” the case. What they do want is to see how well the parents can work together especially when it comes to the child.
If one parent is always trying to keep the child away from the other, constantly bad-mouthing them, or creating tension, judges will take note.
On the flip side, if a parent is cooperative, flexible, and respectful, that goes a long way. Judges want to see that both parents can put their differences aside and focus on what’s best for the child even if that means sharing the time.
The Child’s Age and Preferences
Depending on how old the child is, their opinion might matter too. Older children, especially teenagers, can sometimes tell the court where they want to live. Judges won’t just go with what the kid says especially if they’re being manipulated or if their preference doesn’t seem to line up with their well-being but they do take it into account.
For younger children, it’s more about developmental needs and emotional bonds. For example, a baby or toddler who’s still breastfeeding or extremely attached to one parent might need to stay closer to that parent for now.
But for teens? If a 16-year-old says they want to live with Dad because he helps with school and gives them space, and there’s no major red flag, a judge will listen.
Each Parent’s Living Situation
This one is practical but super important. Judges want to make sure the child has a safe and comfortable place to live. They're asking questions like:
- Is the home clean and safe?
- Does the child have their own bed (even if they share a room)?
- Is the neighborhood safe?
- Is there enough space for the child to do homework, sleep, play?
You don’t need a mansion to win custody, but you do need to show you can provide a nurturing environment.
By the way, some families explore co-living arrangements after separation, like taking up spots in family-oriented housing options, such as Akala Residences, which offer built-in support and secure family-friendly spaces. That kind of stable environment can definitely make a positive impression.
History of Abuse or Neglect
This is a big one. If there’s any history of abuse, neglect, violence, or substance misuse, judges take it very seriously. The safety of the child always comes first.
Even if the abusive behavior wasn’t directed at the child (say, it was between the parents), a judge may decide that the child shouldn’t be placed in that home. And if there's been Child Protective Services (CPS) involvement, those records will come into play.
On the other hand, if a parent has made false allegations just to hurt the other, that can backfire. Judges are trained to spot manipulative behavior, and they don’t appreciate it.
School and Community Ties
Imagine you're 9 years old, and suddenly you have to move away from your school, your best friends, your soccer team, and even grandma just because of a custody ruling. It’s rough, right?
Judges try to avoid that kind of disruption if they can help it. So, they’ll look at how connected the child is to their current school, friends, and broader community.
A parent who can keep the child close to all that, or who is willing to drive them back and forth to maintain those connections, may have the upper hand.
Each Parent’s Mental and Physical Health
Parenting is hard work, especially when doing it solo. Judges want to make sure that each parent is physically and mentally capable of caring for the child. If one parent has unmanaged mental health issues, serious medical problems, or a lifestyle that makes parenting difficult (like frequent travel or irregular hours), that can affect the decision.
But don’t stress having a mental health condition doesn’t automatically disqualify someone. What matters is how it’s managed. If you're seeing a therapist, taking medication as prescribed, and showing up as a stable, present parent, you’re doing right by your child.
Sibling Relationships
If the child has siblings, judges usually want to keep them together unless there’s a strong reason not to. The bond between siblings is a big deal. They’re your built-in support system during tough transitions. That said, if one sibling is from a different relationship and already lives with one parent, or if the siblings don’t get along well, judges might consider splitting them up, but only if it's for the child’s benefit.
Any Agreements Already in Place
If the parents have previously agreed on a plan maybe informally and it’s been working well, judges may honor that. Stability is key, remember?
For example, if the child has been living with Mom for the last six months and doing great, the judge might lean toward keeping things as they are, unless there’s a compelling reason to change it.
Final Thoughts (But Not "In Conclusion"—We Promised!)
So, there you have it. Judges aren’t picking favorites. They’re not trying to punish anyone or reward the person who seems more put-together on the surface. What they’re really doing is trying to find the best possible situation for the child even if it’s not perfect.
If you’re going through a custody battle or just working out a parenting plan, here’s what matters most:
- Be present.
- Be consistent.
- Be cooperative.
- And most of all, focus on your child, not the fight.
Kids are incredibly resilient, but they need steady love, clear routines, and supportive parents who prioritize them over the conflict.
No judge expects perfection. They just want to see effort, love, and responsibility. And honestly, if you’re here reading this because you care, you’re already doing something right.
Now I’d Like to Hear From You!
What does shared parenting mean to you? Have you or someone you know experienced the difference it can make?
Feel free to reply to this email—I’d love to hear your stories and share your voice with our growing community.
Ways to Support
Your contribution helps families access life-changing resources and support. Together, we can make a lasting impact this year.
- Donate to Kids Need Both, Inc.: Make a Donation Here
- Spread the Word: Share our programs with families who could benefit.
- Get Involved: Volunteer with us to make a difference in your community.
Kids Need Both is a 501(c)3 non-profit organization dedicated to empowering families through critical resources and support. With your help, we can promote healthier relationships and stronger communities.
When you contribute, you’re not just giving financially—you’re providing hope, opportunity, and the chance for a better future. Every donation makes a lasting impact. You can make a one-time gift of any amount that feels right to you. Alternatively, you can subscribe with a recurring contribution of $5/mo, $15/mo, or $25/mo. If you’re interested in a custom recurring gift option, I’d be happy to set that up for you—just send me an email with “support” in the subject line.
Thank you so much for being part of this journey. Your support, whether through reading, sharing, or contributing, means the world to me. Together, we’re building something meaningful that I hope will create lasting, positive change. I’m grateful to have you along for the ride!
Thank you for being part of the Hope 4 Families community. Wishing you love, understanding, and meaningful connections!
Be Blessed,
Danica Joan Dockery, M.Ed.
Executive Director, Kids Need Both, Inc.
